The 2011 live-action film Gantz is a two-part sci-fi thriller based on the manga series of the same name. It follows two young men, Kei Kurono and Masaru Kato, who die in a train accident and are resurrected in a mysterious room with a black sphere known as "Gantz." The sphere forces them to participate in missions to hunt and kill aliens. The film is considered a watchable but watered-down adaptation of its source material, with fans and critics pointing out its strengths and weaknesses.
Key Themes and Character Arcs
The film explores the emotional journey of its protagonist, Kei Kurono, as he transforms from a self-absorbed and disaffected college student into a more heroic figure. The film focuses on the dynamic between the two main characters, Kurono and Kato, who represent contrasting worldviews. Kurono is initially selfish and unlikable, while Kato is more compassionate and concerned with protecting others. This contrast is a central element of the narrative. The film also touches on themes of morality and what people are willing to do to save themselves or those they love.
Comparison to the Manga and Anime
The live-action film is widely criticized for "toning down" the more explicit and brutal nature of the source material. The manga is known for its extreme violence, gore, and unapologetic portrayals of sex and racism. The movie, in contrast, is more sanitized, with carefully obscured nudity and violence that, while still bloody, doesn't reach the "superviolent" level of the manga. This shift in tone makes the film feel "bland" or "tame" to many fans.
The film also significantly alters the plot and character arcs from the manga. It removes many side characters and entire story arcs, which critics argue results in a lack of character development for anyone other than the two leads. The film's ending, particularly in the second part, Gantz: Perfect Answer, is a major departure from the manga's conclusion.
Visuals and Production
One of the film's praised aspects is its visual fidelity to the manga. The live-action version successfully translates the look and feel of the "Gantz room" and the various alien creatures to the screen. The production values and CGI effects are considered to be above average for a Japanese film of its time. The action sequences, while not "bullet ballet" in style, are described as inventive and thrilling. However, some action scenes, particularly in the first film, are criticized for being too dark or shot too closely, making it hard to follow the action.
Reception
The film received a mixed reception. Fans of the manga were often disappointed by the toned-down content and significant plot changes, while general audiences found it to be an entertaining and stylish sci-fi action movie. The English dubbing for the first film was particularly criticized for being "horrible" and "wooden," with many recommending watching the original Japanese version with subtitles.
Ultimately, Gantz is seen as a decent popcorn flick that, while failing to capture the darkness and philosophical depth of its source material, still delivers an enjoyable and action-packed experience for a broad audience.