My Super Psycho Sweet 16[]
| Name | Cause of Death | Killer | On Screen Death |
| Karren | Snapped Neck | Charlie Rotter | No |
| Craig | Impaled in back of head through mouth with broken pool stick | Charlie Rotter | Yes |
| Party Planner | Crooked spear in the stomach/gutted | Charlie Rotter | Yes |
| Kevin Donaldson | Chocked with a chain, beaten repeatedly with a spike-balled mace | Charlie Rotter | Yes |
| Chloe Anderson | Head bashed in witha fire extinguiser | Charlie Rotter | Yes |
| Lily McFadden | Throat sliced with a sword | Charlie Rotter | Yes |
| Olivia Wade | Decapitated by a battle axe/ bodycollided with a sushi tiered cake | Charlie Rotter | Yes |
| Madison Penrose | Throat slit with a knife | Charlie Rotter | No |
My Super Psycho Sweet 16: Part 2[]
| Name | Cause of Death | Killer | On Screen Death |
| Ted Bell | Staabed in the back, strangled with jumper cables in the back of an suv, decapitated
(off-screen) |
Charlie Rotter | Yes |
| Molly Abiko | Electric knife in back of head/forehead split open | Charlie Rotter | Yes |
| Jams Feldman | Hacked up with a meat cleaver | Charlie Rotter | Yes |
| Dereck McNamera | Neck impaled with a nail-board | Charlie Rotter | Yes |
| Courtney Ramirez | Face smashed in with a meat tenderizer | Charlie Rotter | Yes |
| Zoe Chandler | Covered in alcohol/lit on fire by kitchen lighter(accidentally self-inflicted) | Charlie Rotter | Yes |
| Carlyon Bell | Throat slit with a knife | Charlie Rotter | Yes |
| Charlie Rotter | Stabbed in the chest | Skye Rotter | Yes |
My Super Psycho Sweet 16: Part 3[]
| Name | Cause of Death | Killers | On screen |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brynn | Blugeoned with a pool light | Nathan Stillo | Yes |
| Ami | Shot multiple times with a nail gun | Nathan Stillo | Yes |
| Leo Fincher | Throat slit with a knife | Alex Bell |
Yes |
| Nico Velli | Stabbed and then hit in the head with a fire poker | Nathan Stillo | Yes |
| Nathan Stillo | Disembowled with a scythe | Alex Bell | Yes |